Introduction: Amarjeet Sohi’s Federal Comeback
Edmonton Mayor Amarjeet Sohi has announced a temporary leave of absence to pursue a federal political comeback in the upcoming April 28 election. His decision to run as a Liberal candidate in the Edmonton-Southeast riding has sparked discussions about leadership stability at City Hall and its implications for municipal governance. While some applaud his decision as a move to secure Edmonton’s influence in Ottawa, others criticize the timing and impact of his absence.
Sohi’s Political Journey: A History of Shifts
Sohi, who previously served as a Liberal MP and cabinet minister, transitioned to municipal politics after losing his federal seat in 2019. In 2021, he was elected mayor of Edmonton, promising a renewed focus on local governance. His leadership has been marked by key initiatives in transit, infrastructure, and social programs, but has also faced criticism over economic challenges and public safety concerns.
His recent decision to return to federal politics has raised questions about political commitment and ambition. This marks the second time Sohi has stepped away from a municipal role to pursue a higher office, prompting debate over whether public officials should commit to their full terms before seeking new opportunities.
Former Mayor and Councillor Weigh In
Stephen Mandel’s Perspective
Former Edmonton Mayor Stephen Mandel expressed mixed feelings about Sohi’s move, citing concerns about municipal leadership stability.
“This isn’t the most publicly popular council or mayor, and this gives him an opportunity to maybe go gracefully,” Mandel stated.
Mandel also emphasized that municipal governance requires long-term commitment, adding that issues such as policing, transit, and emergency services demand continuous leadership. He expressed doubts about whether Edmonton’s interests would be best served by Sohi’s move to Ottawa, highlighting the challenges of balancing local and national priorities.
Kim Krushell’s View
Former city councillor Kim Krushell, who served alongside Sohi, suggested that his decision aligns with his longstanding passion for federal affairs.
“He has always cared about the federal government. He was in the government, he was a minister, and he negotiated a pipeline,” she noted.
Krushell acknowledged that while some residents might question his move, Sohi’s name recognition could bolster his electoral prospects. She also pointed out that his extensive experience in federal policy-making could allow Edmonton to have a stronger voice in Parliament if he secures a seat.
The Political Implications
Council’s Response and Leadership Void
Edmonton’s city council convened a special meeting to approve Sohi’s unpaid leave of absence. While council members unanimously supported his request, some voiced concerns over governance during his absence. Councillor Andrew Knack pointed out that this scenario has occurred before, stating:
“We’ve now seen this four times since I’ve been on council—twice with Sohi.”
Despite this precedent, Tim Cartmell, a councillor running for mayor, argued that Sohi should have resigned outright, instead of leaving the council in a state of limbo. Cartmell believes that a leader’s primary responsibility is to fulfill their elected term and that leaving midway through disrupts continuity in governance.
Who Will Lead Edmonton in His Absence?
While Sohi campaigns, Deputy Mayor Karen Principe will temporarily assume his responsibilities. However, some experts argue that Edmonton may lack strong leadership during this period.
Mandel fears that council may flounder without a permanent leader, emphasizing that the mayor plays a crucial role in setting the agenda and guiding municipal progress.
“The mayor is the figure that coalesces council, brings them together, and moves an agenda forward,” Mandel explained.
Without a central authority figure, municipal decision-making could become fragmented, potentially affecting key infrastructure projects, budget decisions, and economic policies.
The Bigger Political Picture
Sohi’s decision comes amid what he describes as one of the most consequential federal elections in history. He cited concerns over Canada’s sovereignty, referencing the impact of U.S. tariffs and trade policies under former President Donald Trump.
“Our sovereignty is under attack. (Edmontonians) need to have a voice at the table if Liberals are going to form government.”
Beyond economic concerns, Sohi argues that federal leadership plays a vital role in addressing climate change, infrastructure development, and national security, areas where he believes he can contribute significantly. His supporters claim that his return to federal politics is motivated by a desire to create positive change, rather than personal ambition.
The Future of Edmonton’s Mayoral Office
If elected federally, Sohi has pledged to resign as mayor. However, if unsuccessful, he plans to complete his term without seeking re-election. This raises speculation about potential mayoral candidates, with Knack hinting at a possible run.
“It’s humbling to have people reach out and ask that question,” Knack remarked when asked about his interest in the mayoral race.
Cartmell and other political analysts suggest that Sohi’s departure could create an open field for new candidates, potentially reshaping Edmonton’s political landscape. With municipal elections approaching, the city could see fresh leadership emerge, addressing long-standing concerns over housing affordability, public safety, and economic development.
Conclusion: A Calculated Risk or a Political Gamble?
Sohi’s federal comeback bid presents both opportunities and challenges. While some view it as a strategic move to amplify Edmonton’s voice at the national level, others question the timing and implications for municipal governance. His decision has sparked a broader debate on political accountability and leadership commitment.
With election day approaching, voters must decide whether his move reflects political ambition or a genuine commitment to public service. Will Edmontonians support his federal aspirations, or will his absence from city leadership cost him valuable trust? The outcome of the April 28 election will determine whether Sohi’s gamble was a stepping stone to greater influence or a miscalculated political detour.
